Dean's World

Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

Africa and Aid money

I mentioned this article in the below article on HIV and Africa, but I wanted to link it again because it's truly must-reading: Kenyan economist says, "For God's Sake, Please Stop the Aid!

Read the whole thing.

(Via Andrea.)

Posted by Dean | Permalink | Technorati Trackbacks
Steven Malcolm Anderson (www):
Excellent. He's like the bum who finally stands up and says: "Stop giving me welfare! I don't want to be a bum any more. I want to earn my own living as a free man." Like the slave who says: "Let me off this plantation! I don't want to be a slave any more. I want to earn my own living as a free man." Our foreign aid money, paid for by your taxes, only goes to line the pockets of bureaucrats and dictators. I'm against that.
7.7.2005 3:10pm
Sam Muldia (mail) (www):
It's not as black and white (no pun intended) as the well-off Kenyan puts it. We can't just enforce the du Toit doctrine and pull all aid and just leave it at that. The bureaucrats and dictators will continue to cause famines and commit genocide, killing innocents by the millions. Oh, in a while it'll stop and they'll civilize themselves, but the road will be paved with untold corpses.

Teaching a man to fish is all well and good, but when there are thugs with big clubs standing behind the man, ready to take his catch and crack his skull, you're just encouraging the thugs.

Disband the UN. Create the United Democracies. Make its primary purpose spreading and safekeeping democracy (by force of arms, not baby-blue helmets). Kill all dictators, theocrats, and warlords. Feed those left starving, build houses for those left homeless, institue representative governments and get out once they're self-sufficient and peaceful. A Marshall plan for the world.

It's not going to happen, though. The elitist circle jerk led by the Bob Geldofs and Bonos will continue unabated, and with luck, in a century or so, a small number of African countries might manage to get on their feet in spite of this. Yet again, where would aging rock stars get free promotion if not for the starving masses of Africa?
7.7.2005 6:49pm
Tom Strong (mail):
Again, I'll say it: Both the left and right agree that we need to end our (and Europe's) outrageous agricultural subsidies and create new free trade opportunities to start fixing this mess.

We've got an agreement. Let's do it.
7.7.2005 8:38pm
Dean Esmay:
I'm all for it, Tom, but I must note that the farming community has *huge* sentimental value to countless Americans. Remember "Farm Aid" and all that? We'd see it with a vengeance. The Senate is filled with people who'd filibuster any attempt to end these subsidies, and it would be political suicide for anyone attempting to win the Presidency as tons of rural states would fight it tooth and nail.

It's not that I'm against trying, but I believe we would find that relatively few politicians would risk their necks on this. Either in the US or in Canada or most of Europe.
7.7.2005 11:00pm
Arnold Harris (mail):
The problems of the African continent have grown from bad to worse since the end of the colonial era. Most of countries on that continent are led by blatherskite regimes comprising little more than gang leaders in fancy dress uniforms.

These countries have growing populations of people who have no health services, no skills with which they can get jobs in order to support themselves and their families, no jobs even for those who have the skills, and, essentially, no future at all.

If left to themselves, the African societies will be decimated by starvation, mass death from AIDS and other epicemics, continual inter-tribal wars, and no future in the world except as locations from which the advanced societies will exploit their resources like so many cash crops. All to the accompaniment of energetic dancers jumping up and down in the dust in colorful costumes keeping time to chanted music.

But the fact is, nobody is going to do anything for any of them. And all the talk in all the international conferences will constitute just more of the same bull-shit we and the Africans hear each year whenever the international news media lashes the liberals into their annual frenzy over Africa and its endless problems.

Arnold Harris
Mount Horeb WI
7.8.2005 12:15am
Steven Malcolm Anderson (www):
Sam Muldia wrote:
"Teaching a man to fish is all well and good, but when there are thugs with big clubs standing behind the man, ready to take his catch and crack his skull, you're just encouraging the thugs."

Then we, America, must smash the thug's skull with our bigger club.
7.8.2005 11:27am