Dean's World

Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

The Poverty/Terrorism "Root Cause" Myth

Art Chrenkoff notes a recent in-depth study which punctures the "poverty is the root cause of terrorism" nonsense. Click here to read about it.

In a related note, Athena has a photo and story of another terrorist that dispels the whole "poverty is the root cause of terrorism" nonsense. Click here to view it.

Honestly, anyone spouting gibberish about poverty causing terrorism really ought to be called out as a bigot. I've known lots of poor people in my time, and I've never seen any evidence that being poor makes them violent killers.

In fact, if you look at terrorists, they usually have one thing in common. Whether it's an anarchist like Ted "Unabomber" Kaczynski, a communist like Che Guevara, or a religio-fascist like Osama bin Laden, all seem to share a common background:

They grew up as spoiled brats in very comfortable, pampered, well-off households.

Other than that, only hate is their unifying trait.

Posted by Dean | Permalink | Technorati Trackbacks
Mark Noonan (mail) (www):
Dean,

There was a line in the Rodney Dangerfield movie Back to School which explains a lot of "revolutionary" thought; looking at a spike-haired, highly pierced student, Dangerfield opined "you look like you're still trying to piss off your parents." These sons (and, sometimes, daughters) of privilege who make up the bulk of the terrorists are, after all is said and done, just really mad at the sterile society they live in and are lashing out in the most self-regarding manner possible...even a suicide bomber is merely doing a "more purer than thou" act taken to exceptional extremes.

It is as if in reaction to the imperfections of society, some determine that they must find the perfect cause and pursue it with a fanaticism which admits no errors and must consume itself in blood. You and I and the rest of the normal world look at the imperfections and go, "heh, what ya gonna do?" and go on...people like the suicide bomber (or the Jacobins, the Bolsheviks, the Stormtroopers, etc) go "you must bend to my will!!!" And if the pieces don't all fit, they'll break off pieces until they do.

The bad news is that we can't really do anything to stop people from developing these lines of thought; even an attempt to proscribe the teaching of the hate-inspiring philosophies wouldn't work because idiocy can just be re-created from scratch. The only thing we can do, and we're doing it, is to try and set up social/political/economic systems which relegate these lunatics to the fever swamps.
4.4.2005 5:31am
Kevin D:
I'd say the "common stereotype" has stuck around because it makes it very easy to blame the Western World (where all the money is supposed to be) for subjecting poor nations to it's tyrannical thirst for weath at the expense of those poor nations' resources. The idea that we're actually paying someone (I'm lookin' at you OPEC) for those resources never seems to come up. I mean, terrorists have to get their money for equipment, weapons and facilities from somewhere, right?

So, I guess if we want to stop terrorism we need to stop buying oil from the Middle East and concentrate on using our own resources. Something George W. Bush wanted to do the day he stepped into office but had every enviomentalist nutbag in the nation screaming.

And then they go fill their SUV with premium knowing they scored one for mother nature.

Ugh... the whole situation stinks.
4.4.2005 7:10am
Dave Schuler (mail) (www):
The profile for terrorists is the same as for revolutionaries and for serial killers: male, 18-35, higher than average intelligence, frequently from middle class or upper-middle class homes.
4.4.2005 1:56pm
Bryan AWS (mail) (www):
The one significant exception to your hypothesis being Charles Manson, who was definitely not from a middle-class family, although he did prey on the children of middle class.
4.4.2005 2:31pm
Dave Schuler (mail) (www):
Was Manson a serial killer or a spree killer? It makes little difference—a profile is not a rule it's just a rule-of-thumb.
4.4.2005 5:11pm
Arnold Harris (mail):
I'm depraved on accounta I'm deprived.

Arnold Harris
Mount Horeb WI
4.6.2005 1:03am