Dean's World

Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

I May Need Your Help

Well, where to begin?

I just found out that my mother was arrested. It's difficult to describe the range of emotions this brings up, but they're probably not what you would think.

Last night, during one of her most profound delusional states (her level of lucidity varies like the weather in Chicago), she once again was believing that the FBI, the Department of Homeland Security, and illegal aliens from Mexico were tapping her phones, monitoring her from outside her apartment, and planning to get her, and she apparently completely lost control.

The 911 call center in San Antonio has received so many phone calls from her over the last year or so that they no longer respond to her. (That's right. She calls 911 so often they now just hang up on her.) But apparently a neighbor, noticing just how loud, irrational, and dangerous her behavior was, called on her behalf. Police had to be called in when she physically attacked the emergency medical technicians who responded.

No one was seriously hurt thank goodness, and it looks like she's to be held for 30 to 60 days by the state of Texas for psychiatric evaluation.

While Rosemary and I are quite open on our weblog about our private lives, this is something I normally wouldn't bring up. After all, it's my mother, not me. However, we know that my mother has been privately corresponding in email with a number of people who read our weblogs. We don't mind this per se--she's not a well woman and she does need friends--but we have no idea (well only some idea anyway) what she's been saying to people.

Of the few of you that I know have been corresponding with her, I have tried to explain that she is mentally ill. Most of you believed it but I'm not certain you understood just how deep the rabbit hole goes. For years my sister and I have been convinced that she's schizophrenic, and not just mildly so. I've spent endless hours poring over medical texts, including the DSM-IV, and I'm quite certain we're correct about this.

I could fill your ear with endless details, but let me just put it this way: Did you ever see A Beautiful Mind? Yeah, well, it's pretty much exactly like that, only not (so far) with a happy ending.

However, she has frustrated any and all attempts we've made to get her properly diagnosed and treated. She's been in and out of psychiatric care, usually short term, and usually diagnosed as having either nervous or mood disorders, and treated with tranquilizers or antidepressants. But she would never let us talk to any of her doctors, and any time we've tried to explain to police who've been called during one of her violent episodes, they've told us that unless they specifically witness something beyond erratic behavior there's nothing they can do. And she always pulls herself together and manages to behave normally when authority figures are around.

Now we've apparently got her in a place where she's going to be under direct observation--and since the law is involved, we're pretty sure we're going to be allowed to at least talk to those doctors. The woman is far more mentally ill than most people ever suspect.

We're going to do our best this time, and here is where I'm hoping some of you might be able to help:

If she's been sending any of you any weird emails, I'd very, very, very, very, very, very, VERY much like copies of those. At least if there's anything in the least bit odd in them. Showing those to doctors should aid in a proper diagnosis, for I have no doubt that they'll show things that simply make no sense for a normally stable person to say.

We get mails from her all the time, so I can tell you there's nothing she could have told any of you that would embarass or anger me. Nothing. It won't be anything different from what I've heard before from her--I've known this woman is insane for almost 20 years now, and you have no idea how many weird things she's told me about herself, about me, about relatives, about friends, and about people I've never even met--or people who quite possibly don't even exist.

My sister will be travelling to Texas soon and will be doing everything she can to talk to my mother's doctors and give them as much documentation as possible. I can't go, but I can certainly telephone and, more important, forward to my sister any emails I've received, or that anyone else has received, that document bizarre behavior or beliefs.

So I normally wouldn't ask, but if you've got any emails from this woman, please, I need to see them. Don't worry about violating her privacy because she's very, very ill and needs your help, not your protection. Nor are you going to embarass me.

Just send it, please. We have an opportunity here, one that may not happen again for a long, long time. God knows, the next incident with the police might not end so well.

If you've heard from her, please tell me about it. Please.

Posted by Dean | Permalink | Technorati Trackbacks
jane m:
Dean

I've not received any e-mails to pass on but I've just got to say how very grieved I am to hear of your mother's condition. I will keep her in my prayers. This is very sad news.
12.1.2004 12:28am
Mrs. du Toit (www):
I didn't save any, but as you know these were long ago.

If your sister is coming to the Dallas area, and needs a place to stay, well... you know our doors is open.
12.1.2004 12:44am
Oschisms (mail) (www):
I ain't religious, but:

God bless your family, Dean &Queen, it'll get back together soon enough, I hope.
12.1.2004 2:14am
rmschoon:
Dean and Rosemary, and sis,

I've never corresponded with your mom, but I really wanted y'all to know I'm sorry this is happening to you. I also wanted you to know I'll be thinking and praying for you and the entire family.

I understand you don't like to air "dirty laundry" but letting those readers who e-mail mom know is a good thing. I'm sure your readers will help out in any way they can.

I don't mean to pry, but where exactly is she? I may have some ideas how to procede in getting the docs to pay attention if I know what system she's in, and which one you'll be dealing with. You can e-mail me if you'd prefer, and I'll help out as best a San Antonian abroad can.

Take care, and you're in my thoughts and prayers.
12.1.2004 2:46am
Dean Esmay (www):
We should find out in the morning where she is. The cops my sister talked to weren't sure, University of Texas medical center maybe? We should get the complete police report in the morning. We hope.
12.1.2004 3:20am
Jim Ausman (mail):
God bless Dean.

I have a schizophrenic brother who lives here on the streets of San Francisco, so I have some small idea what you must be going through.

She has sent me no email, alas.
12.1.2004 3:37am
Paul Burgess (www):
Dean, will do. And please let me know if there's any other way I can help at this time. I'm keeping all you folks— and most especially your mother— in my prayers.
12.1.2004 6:25am
Mike (mail):
Nope, nothing here, man.
You have my sympathy for what it's worth. I know people who have had mental illness and its real hard on everyone.

Chin up, friend.
12.1.2004 7:26am
Sandi (www):
Dean, best wishes to you, Rosemary and your families. I have had enough problems in my own family to know what you are going through. You are all in my prayers.
12.1.2004 8:44am
Will B. (mail) (www):
I don't know about Powerblogs, but most other blogging software has an underlying database you can query. It should be possible to query that database for comments left by your mother.

If there is anything I can do to help, please let me know.
12.1.2004 8:53am
Chris Lansdown (mail) (www):
Will, (Dean,)

Actually, Dean can do that through the comment moderation interface. All he has to do is go to moderate comments left by his mother's account and he'll be able to see them all.
12.1.2004 9:58am
caltechgirl (www):
Well, UT Southwestern Med center in Dallas has some of the best schizophrenia docs in the country. If she's schizophrenic she's in good hands, and if not, they should be able to give you an answer. Prayers and good wishes for all of you, I know this is difficult. I'm hoping your mom will get on some good meds and have a chance to stay on them long enough that things even out for all of you.
12.1.2004 12:03pm
urthshu (mail) (www):
That's an awful bind, Dean. And I do hope it works out for the best.
It isn't any wonder that the Dr.s won't give you much medical information- that's a privacy issue. They'll want to know from you if she's made threats vs. herself or others, mainly. If so, that'll open a door to further treatment.
Do you know if Texas has mandated medication laws? I'm not personally in favor of these laws, myself [coercion by the state to support a commercial product or medical procedure- good debating question, BTW] but you might, so I'm putting that option out there.
Other than all that, maybe Dr. Sanity can give you some good advice? http://drsanity.blogspot.com/
12.1.2004 12:28pm
Dave in Texas (mail):
Very sorry to hear that. Hang in there.
12.1.2004 12:35pm
Omnibus Driver (mail) (www):
I'll be praying for your entire family.
12.1.2004 3:14pm
just me:
my mother was mentally ill and one other family member was bipolar. it's very very difficult to live with those conditions as the other members of the family.

i'll keep you in my prayers.
12.1.2004 8:41pm
just me:
one last thing, a number of people who have hormone imbalances, such as cushings, hyper/hypothyroidism among others, have been diagnosed as mentally ill before the real problem was diagnosed and treated.

in fact, dr. john cushings found the first few cushings' patients in a mental institution. and more recently, a study found that many women were diagnosed with alzheimers when what they actually had were low thyroid values. when the cushings patients were treated, they were normal; when the wrongly diagnosed women were treated with thyroid hormones, they also became normal.

not everything that looks like a duck and quacks like a duck is really a duck. speaking from experience, not just from what i've read.
12.1.2004 8:44pm
urthshu (mail) (www):
True...but thats a fairly rare thing. I ran acrost one guy that had severe sleep apnea to the point where he never entered REM sleep over the course of 10 years, which made him very loopy, but thats out of perhaps 200 people I met with moderate to severe mental illness during a 2 year period as a counselor. Notably I did not spot it- he sought another diagnosis.
Generally, moderate to severe mental illness fills a number of criteria- if, after eliminating biological causation, it falls under NOS [Not Otherwise Specified] my antennae go up for other causes.
My highly abbreviated method of course. Not necessarily the same for all.
12.1.2004 10:35pm
Joe Katzman, Winds of Change.NET (www):
Dean,

I've been here before.

You have an advantage, and a window - and more to worry about next time than just the police. Press youre advantage with everything you've got, without relenting. This illness is often FATAL, so conduct yourselves accordingly re: boxing her in on treatment, meds, etc.

Really, do whatever it takes - even if it makes you feel bad. Anything less than that can make you feel worse by several orders of magnitude.

I'd add that in addition to an archive of emails she has sent, signed statements by San Antonio 9/11 that they won't take her calls would be a good idea. That, and journals (Word files) by people who know her that records the date, approximate time, and nature of bizarre or dangerous/self-destructive actions and/or statements.

Those are very useful if you ever need to put together quick affadavits for involuntary commitment, which you probably will need to do a couple of times down the road when she goes off her meds.

If the docs can find a happy side-cause, great. If not, then the battle is just beginning. The medications for treating psychotic mood disorders have side effects, but they will keep her alive.

2 cents from someone who has been there.
12.2.2004 1:38pm
red (www):
Dean, friend,

As you know I've been traveling quite a bit over the last month and am just reading this now. I am truly sorry to hear of this ... and I will keep your family in my thoughts.

As you also know, your mother has indeed corresponded a bit with me, but I do not have those emails - I just looked. She's made quite a few comments on my blog, would those help you out?

I'll keep her in my thoughts. I have known and loved people with this illness - and it is wrenching indeed to be a part of it.

Best to you.

Sheila
12.2.2004 2:56pm