Dean's World

Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

Hinderocker & Jarvis On QaQaaGate

Don't miss the transcript of John Hinderocker and Jeff Jarvis from CNBS, on QaQaaGate, the ginned-up, partisan-hack New York Times/CBS story on "missing" explosives in Iraq.

Oh, and, uh, don't miss how 3 seems to equal 380.

Posted by Dean | Permalink | Technorati Trackbacks
Chris Lansdown (mail) (www):
Dean,

Actually, it's that 3 equals about 180; only the quantity of RDX is in question, the quantity of HMX isn't, and that accounts for about half of it, the article said.

But what's even better in that article is that the IEAE weapons inspectors did note that their seals probably wouldn't do anything to keep people with screwdrivers from removing the chemicals:
...the inspectors said the seals may be potentially ineffective because they had ventilation slats on the sides. These slats could be easily removed to remove the materials inside the bunkers without breaking the seals, the inspectors noted.
10.28.2004 8:24am
Mike (mail):
What was to prevent the Iraqi government from counterfeiting the seals, removing the IAEA seals, taking out what they want, and putting counterfeit seals back up? What do these seals look like? What are they made of? How easy would it be to counterfeit them? Would the IAEA even complain if they found out they were scammed?

Just questions that have been running through my slimy, yet aigle, mind.
10.28.2004 9:03am
Chris Lansdown (mail) (www):
Mike,

I think that we need to give the IAEA basic credit for competence, though how much honesty we need credit them with I don't know. But even they said (see the second article Dean linked) that the seals could have easily been circumvented through the vents.
10.28.2004 9:22am
Mike (mail):
Chris:
I've reached the point of skepticism with any UN agency. Basic competence has to be proved first before I will grant it. Not placing seals on vents large enough to pass through? Sounds like we have another winner there. Dishonest - well, that would be the point, I think. Who else would be the guys to bribe but the inspectors? I wonder what their bank balances look like?
10.28.2004 1:12pm