Dean's World

Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

My Skin Is Not White

Okay, first off, I want to make it clear that I have no agenda behind this question. Honestly, I don't.

In the early 1970s, certain folks decided that the polite way to refer to people of African descent with dark skin and curly hair was "black." Before that, you would (if you weren't rude) refer to a white person as "caucasian" and a black person as "negro." That was just the way people talked. But that became unaccepable, and after that we would refer to pale-skinned Europeans as "white" and dark-skinned Africans as "black."

But am I the only one who thinks this was a bad move?

"Black." To me this is a bad word. Black is a negative color. If I'm in a black mood I'm angry. If I indulge in black humor I'm being cynical about the human race. If I'm wearing black clothes, it's because I'm in mourning. If you study physics, you learn that black is the absence of color. Basically, black is a negative.

So why would anyone want to be a "black person?"

I'm considered a white man. I don't really relate to that though. My skin is not white. It's a sort of peach color unless I've got a tan on, in which case it's a very light brown. But it's never white. Indeed, if I said "my face went white," it would mean all the color had drained out of it because I was freaked out and upset.

I have never met a person with black skin. I've met people with beautiful dark brown skin though. Indeed, the prettiest girl I ever dated (other than my beautiful pale-skinned wife) grew up in Harlem and had skin the color of walnuts. Her lips were lush and gorgeous, her hair curly like wool, her nose somewhat flat but perky.

Indeed, in my world, the most beautiful woman alive (other than The Queen of course) is Halle Berry. So, well, I guess it's a dumb question, but:

Why use such a negative word to describe such beautiful people?
Posted by deanesmay | Permalink | Technorati Trackbacks
La Shawn Barber (mail) (www):
Because I loathe "African-American." Actually, I'd rather be called an America. But if my race comes into play, just refer to me as "black." I don't think of the word as negative, although it has various negative connotations. It denotes my "race" rather than my skin color. It's just a quick way to describe people.

If you absolutely hate the word and don't want to use it to describe someone on my ethnicity, you may refer to me as "an American of African descent."
7.6.2004 6:54am
Smelly Duck (mail):
I tend to agree with you, Dean, but it does beg the question: Why did God assign us such crappy colors to begin with? How about a nice pastel blue or green? Black, white, brown and yellow was a bad choice.
7.6.2004 7:12am
Arnold Harris (mail):
I'm with you about Halle Berry. Anyway, she doesn't look particularly white and she doesn't look particularly black. And who gives a shit? She does look like a lady that you dream about getting onto a bed with, if you're a normal hetero male.

Racism to me is nothing, unlike culturism, which is everything.

Bu the way. Why in hell am I being logged in as "unkwnown" every time I put in my password on this new and slightly pitiful exxuse for good old Dean's World, when in fact both you and your computer system know perfectly well that I am the one and only...

Arnold Harris
Mount Horeb WI
7.6.2004 9:10am
peg kaplan (mail) (www):
Dean--

I love the color black. Have plenty of it in my home, my clothes, my art - well, you get the idea.

That the word "black" sometimes has negative connotations shouldn't stop us from using it appropriately and appreciating it!

On the other hand, I'm with Arnold. I hate the constant references to race that permeate our society. I see, however, no getting away from it in the near future, given the mindset of the media and the liberal left.

I also have always wondered.... why is it that those who are roughly half black and half something else - white, asian, etc. - are always referred to as black? Why isn't Lani Gunier (sp?) a Jewish woman? Why does Tiger Woods' black heritage always get top billing?

I'm not saying that there is anything wrong with it being "on top." But why does "black" always trump anything else?

Maybe I will be alive to see the day when people care about as much about a person's race as they do about whether they have curly or straight hair.

Hope so.

Peg K
7.6.2004 10:21am
Scott Kirwin (mail):
Some of the most beautiful women I've ever seen had skin the color of au lait with heavy cream - in Zanzibar. Second place goes to the women in South Korea who had skin the color of... who gives a damn. They were freaking gorgeous.
7.6.2004 10:22am
La Shawn Barber (mail) (www):
Yes, yes, all the colors of the rainbow are beautiful, gorgeous. But would you marry a "black woman?
7.6.2004 11:11am
Ara Rubyan (mail) (www):
"Black." To me this is a bad word. Black is a negative color. If I'm in a black mood I'm angry. If I indulge in black humor I'm being cynical about the human race. If I'm wearing black clothes, it's because I'm in mourning. If you study physics, you learn that black is the absence of color. Basically, black is a negative.

Exactly so. So it shouldn't be hard for you to understand the sentiments express here:
"We've been brainwashed. Everything good is supposed to be white. We look at Jesus, and we see a white with blond hair and blue eyes. We look at all the angels; we see white with blond hair and blue eyes. Now, I'm sure there's a heaven in the sky an it colored folks die and go to heaven. Where are the colored angels? They must be in the kitchen preparing milk and honey. We look at Miss America, we see white. We look at Miss World, we see white. We look at Miss Universe, we see white. Even Tarzan, the king of the jungle in black Africa, he's white. White Owl Cigars. White Swan soap, White Cloud tissue paper, White Rain hair rinse, White Tornado floor wax. All the good cowboys ride the white horses and wear white hats. Angel food cake is the white cake, but the devils food cake is chocolate. When are we going to wake up as a people and end the lie that white is better than black?"


7.6.2004 11:22am
Chris Reid (www):
The sick thing was back during the '90s, when PC craziness was at its height, even people outside America were referred to as "African American". It ceased to even make sense. "Oh, there are lots of African Americans in Africa..."
7.6.2004 11:34am
Dean Cochrane:
La Shawn, of course I'd marry a black woman. Unfortunately (or fortunately, if you're me) I met a wonderful, wonderful woman some years ago, and she'd be quite upset if I married a black woman.

But if I had met her, and she happened to have skin that was darker than mine, I'd still marry her.

I live near Vancouver, where interracial marriage is common. There are few black people, but there are many, many people whose ancestors (note how I phrased that?) come from India, China, Taiwan, Japan, the Phillipines, etc. They marry 'white' people and other Asian people with impunity. Nobody under the age of 80 gives a mixed-race couple a second glance any more.

And that's how it should be.

BTW: some of the most beautiful women I have ever seen (I mean stunning: jaw-dropping, eye-bulging STUNNING) come from India. My wife and I sometimes watch the Bollywood movies on the local TV channels just to see them.
7.6.2004 11:40am
lindsey (mail):
The thing is that in most cultures isn't the association usually with black negative and with white positive? In European literature going back before most Europeans had even met an African white was associated with good and black with bad. I don't think we're going to be able to stamp out this association. It's probably better to be honest: there are no white or black people.

Also, about Jesus, you have to realize that Jesus wasn't Aryan to begin with. All people make Jesus to look like themselves. So if you live in a culture where the majority of the people are white Jesus will usually look white.
7.6.2004 12:38pm
Rachel Ann Anolick (mail) (www):
White doesn't always have such a good conptation either; white as in leporsy. In some cultures white is the color of mourning and death.

In Judaism white is the color of purity, but its opposite would be red (sin).

Skin color is always a variation of brown.

7.6.2004 12:55pm
MontieBurchett:
Dean, I can't say why we use the designators we use, I think it can mostly be blamed on the political correctness movement. It really can be quite confusing when you deal with it from a law enforcement perspective. Just yesterday, another officer and I were out with a young couple on a call. They were married (common-law) and in the course of our contact the other officer was running them for "record and wanted" I heard him give the female's race as Black (based solely on her looks). I told him he needed to verify that with her, and he looked puzzled. I said " Her name would indicate some Hispanic heritage, so ask her what she considers herself to be." Sure enough, when he directly asked her what race she was she unhesitatingly said "Hispanic".

Oh and to answer La Shawn's question, absolutely I would marry a black woman. I have never let an artificial barrier like skin color keep me from befriending, dating, or anything else, people I find interesting. Of course, if they look and think like you La Shawn, then it would be "when can we set the date!"
7.6.2004 2:51pm
Dean Esmay (www):
Yeah I think the association of white with purity is pretty strong simply because white shows dirt and stains so well that if something's truly white you can tell it's clean. Also white clouds are pretty.

But extremely white skin is unnatural and creepy looking. If I say "my face turned white!" or "you're white as a ghost!" those aren't positive things. Ghosts are spooky and white in our cultural mythology.

So I guess maybe it is just a word. It's somewhat more descriptive than "colored" (like white people are colorless?). Then you go back to the old "caucasion/negro" thing and that doesn't make sense since the Caucussus mountains run through Armenia and Iraq, which would make Iraqis "caucasions" and not those pale Germans and Brits.

I dunno, it's a weird hangup. Peg also makes a good point how we consider people black even if they're really only half or quarter or whatever. And I've met people from India whose skin was much darker tha most black pepole's but they aren't considered black.

Bah humbug. It's a silly mess isn't it?
7.6.2004 3:26pm
Dean Esmay (www):
Ooh, a new internet romance forming?
7.6.2004 3:27pm
Steven Malcolm Anderson (www):
I refuse to use "African-American". Primarily because it's a shibboleth coined by that despicable Jesse Jackson to discriminate between those who show him proper obeisance and those us who refuse to do so. Also, it takes too long to say (which is why he coined it as a shibboleth).

Also, it's confusing. A Negro whose ancestors have been here since before George Washington was born is equated with, e.g., a first-generation immigrant from Nigeria or, ironically, with Kim du Toit, a "white" man who came here from South Africa.

And, if I have to say "African-American", why then, I absolutely insist on calling myself a "European-American". But that's wrong, too, because _culturally_ we are all Europeans regardless of skin color. Like Arnold Harris (good to see you here!), I am a culturist, not a racist.

If you want to be a racist, then you must recognize that the albinos are the only True White Race. All the pinkish, beigish, peach people should be purged out of the Klan.

Black and white. Interesting. Yes, black is historically associated with night and darkness, and therefore with evil. That's precisely why it's used by some S&M lovers. White is also negative, though, in that it is a skeletal, ghostly, or ash color, a color of death. Yet both can be beautiful.

In ancient Egypt, black was the color of the fertile soil irrigated by the Nile, therefore of life and prosperity, therefore of the good, and was associated with Osiris. Red, by contrast, was the color of the sterile sands of the desert, and was therefore associated with evil and with Set.

Colors, colors, colors, colors.... I love colors. Colors I do love.

I love that old word "Negro" (with a capital "N"). It has a look and sound of nobility and dignity. I love what it connotes. It was used during the ages when the "civil rights" movement really did stand for equality before the law, for justice, for individual freedom and dignity. I love the very fact that is so archaic and "square". The style. Negro.

Holy Dawn and her holy Negro wife Norma.

I also love the beautiful feminine form "Negress".
7.6.2004 3:28pm
MontieBurchett:
Dean, I should be so LUCKY! My admiration for La Shawn is all your fault anyway, since I linked to her site from yours. I must say that since the first time I began reading her blog it has supplanted yours as the first one I read every day, because I like what she has to say, and how she says it. Sorry... but yours is still the next in line:-)
7.6.2004 3:58pm
Juliette Ochieng (mail) (www):
Concur with Chris Reid. The impreciseness of the term "African American" is confusing for the dimmer among us. I have a post on my site as to why I don't use it. (My father is an actual African; never was a US citizen.)
7.6.2004 4:08pm
La Shawn Barber (mail) (www):
Well Montie, I do like a man in uniform...
7.6.2004 4:15pm
MontieBurchett:
La Shawn, You know it has never been a problem that our desks in the investigations office face each other (as in "NYPD Blue"), but upon clicking back here to see any other comments before leaving today, I reacted enough to your post that the officer across from me said "Hey are you OK, you look awfully flushed":-)
7.6.2004 4:58pm
Steven Malcolm Anderson (www):
Back in the 1950s, someone wrote an excellent book: "Communism vs. the Negro"

How true.

"Colored people"? "People of color?" Hmmm.... I agree with Smelly Duck that we would look more colorful in blues and greens. Reds and purples, too? Hmmm....
7.6.2004 5:08pm
Dean Esmay (www):
Send her an email, Montie.

Go on. She doesn't bite. :-)
7.6.2004 5:10pm
Andrew Cory (mail) (www):
The other day, my Father and I were waiting around for my Step Mother to finish getting ready for a 4th of July party. To kill time, we flipped on the TV and discovered Halle Berry popping out of the water in the latest James Bond movie. We decided that this must be a sign from God that we were meant to be watching this program...

Those of us whose primary ancestry goes back to the Mediterranean are referred to as having “olive” skin. Thus, when _absolutely forced_, I’ll refer to myself as being “green”...

Finally, I don’t know why, but we’ve used some derivation of “black” to describe people of African Descent for quite a long time: “N----“and “Negro” both mean “Black” in (I think) Latin and Spanish respectively. So the switch to “black” was just the latest in a long line of attempts to de-profane the term...
7.6.2004 5:45pm
lindsey (mail):
Here's a good article deailing with Cosby's comments and what teachers are encountering in the public school system.
7.6.2004 6:35pm
Sigivald (mail):
(registering for comments? Like I can remember ANOTHER password? Sweet zombie Mahomet!)

Remember, Dean, physics also teaches us that when we're talking about color of pigments black is what you get when you combine all your pigments. (Well, okay, you get dark brown, if you have enough light pigment. But still.)

Physics doesn't really teach us anything about the "positive" or "negative" meaning of a color, honest.

"Black"'s major problem isn't that it's negative, but that it's both inaccurate (most "black" people being, in actuality, brown), and that it doesn't tell us anything significant. What's skin color even matter, apart from mere aesthetics?
7.6.2004 7:36pm
Little Miss Attila (mail) (www):
I don't mind "black," because it's simple and understandable, and I don't see it as negative (little black dresses, black cars, onyx earrings, etc.--so much beauty). Context always tells us whether the word/idea "black" means something negative ("seduced by the dark side," "black magic") or simply race. And it's not uncommon to have one word mean radically different things, based on context. I do, however, think we would have been better off sticking with "Negro," because there was nothing wrong with it. (I believe David Horowitz has posited that changing over to "black" in the 60s and "African American" in the 90s is just a way for poverty pimps like Jesse Jackson to keep white culture jumping "[you're a racist unless you change your terminology every 30 years!"])

I don't mind Caucasian, because it's just a clinical term for round-eyed people with relatively thin lips (because as I understand it it does encompass Native Americans, Latinos, and Indian Indians--some of whom have dark skin). No harm there.

I despise it when people refer to "Arabs" as nonwhite. They are Caucasian (in the racial sense). Most of them look like they could be Jewish or Italian--so why pretend they are a different race? That seems to me just a step removed (if that) from the white supremicists who maintain that Jews aren't white.

And I hate hate hate the use of white to mean "not Latino."

I'm afraid that "if a little bit black, all the way black" is a concept left over from the Jim Crow days.

We should all refuse to check their little boxes as a matter of principle and practicality; I certainly did the last time they took a census here. Besides, I don't know how much Native American ancestry I have--but believe me, it's small.
7.7.2004 5:55am
Account:
Password:
Remember info?
Commenting on Dean's World is a privilege, not a right. Dean is your host, you are his guest, and you should behave in that fashion. Dean is not your babysitter, nor is he your punching bag. Please remember this. In general, you are free to disagree with anyone on any subject you wish, but abusive behavior will not be tolerated.

Of course we all lose our tempers now and then. Dean freely admits to being imperfect in this regard, which is why regulars to this establishment will generally be cut more slack than people who we don't know very well.

Still: behave like an adult, or go find somewhere else to play. Thanks.