Dean's World
 Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

.:: Dean's World: 1950 ::.

January 18, 2004

1950

In El Paso, Texas, in the summer of 1966, a girl named Mary gave birth to her second son.

Her first son had been born in 1964, and given up for adoption. She had absolutely refused to have the abortion her grandmother wanted her to have, and her family was in no condition to take care of the new child. That first son's father had been the owner of a night club for teenagers there in El Paso, and was also an up-and-coming rock star. Today he is best known for the big national hit "I Fought The Law (& The Law Won)," although he also had several regional hits in places like Texas and California, and everyone expected him to make it very big very soon. The scandal of having a bastard child would have ruined him, though, especially because he was in his 20s and the girl was so young. She was madly in love with him and wanted to marry him, but was too young legally to do so. So all concerned among the families decided the child must be given up for adoption--although they didn't bother much with asking the young mother what she wanted to do.

Eventually, the rock star died an untimely and mysterious death in California, under obscure circumstances no one quite understands. It was officially ruled a suicide, although the family to this day still doesn't believe it. In any case, you can still find excellent collections of this man's music, which feature shockingly good recording quality, almost digital quality, even though almost all his hits were recorded in his home studio in El Paso in the mid-60s. Bobby Fuller was quite gifted both musically and as a recording engineer. Although his taste for young girls seems rather deplorable in retrospect, it seems he was rather shocked to learn just how young she was. Like many teenaged girls she looked and acted a good bit older than she was, and very much enjoyed the company of men. Especially musicians. Especially him.

Interestingly, in the 1980s, Mary managed to make contact with her long-lost first biological son. She also became deeply involved in a national movement to help birth parents and adoptees to find each other, and had significant influence in getting legislation passed to make it easier for both children and birth parents to find each other (if they wanted to). During those years, Mary was also deeply involved in and committed to the Pro-Life movement. But all that was many years away, and in those early days, young Mary did her best not to think too much about her first son, and almost never talked about him to anyone.

So, having been born herself in 1950, young Mary was only 16 years old at the time her second son was born. After becoming pregnant, she had married that boy's father, a fellow teenager named Richard. The name "Dean' being something of a family tradition for the Esmays (going back to an ancestor who married a woman named Laura Dean), they named the boy Dean. Four years later, his sister Kristine was born.

They weren't really very good days for the young couple, although they made a brave go of it at first. Neither one of them'd had what you could call a healthy upbringing as children, mental illness and alcoholism having plagued parts of both of their families. Mary's young husband's upbringing was particularly rough; his parents having been such severe alcoholics that their children often had to fend for themselves for days at a time and sometimes didn't eat. Young Richard's mother eventually killed herself when he was just a child. Many, many years later, he told his (adult) son that when that happened, he'd felt nothing.

Young Mary's family tried to be supportive of the young couple, but her parents had divorced, and her mother and grandmother left the country to work in the Civil Service in Okinawa. This left only Mary's father, her paternal grandmother, and her older brother (all of 20 years old himself) for support, and, being poor, none of them could do much more than offer their presence and guidance. Richard's father was friendly enough when he was sober, but never offered much in the way of moral or emotional support.

In the beginning, however, when their first son together was born, young Richard worked hard at his job with the phone company, and tried to be a good provider for Mary and their child. He was very proud to do it. Unfortunately, at the age of 17, the stresses of work and fatherhood were too much for the young man, and he had difficulty coping. He also had no emotional support structure to fall on except his young wife and his infant child. He began drinking heavily, badly out of control much of the time, and, while he was usually a very gentle, friendly, funny person, when he drank his inner demons would often come out. He occasionally became violent and abusive while drunk. Sometimes, to a frightening and dangerous degree. There was many a time when young Mary had to flee the house with her children because he'd been drinking and was on a tear again. Other times her young son hid in the tree in their back yard, or under his bed, while the fighting was going on.

The divorce was, in the end, an inevitability.

It was easy for Mary's young son to hate his father for all that sometimes. It was also easy for him to hate his mother for rushing into having a child at such an age and under such circumstances. She'd wanted that baby back, and forcing a young man into a shotgun wedding before either of them was ready just so she could have another one was hardly the most responsible choice. But now that her son is 37 years old, he sees the situation for what it was: troubled teenagers desperately trying to cope in a frightening and difficult and painful world, still nursing their own internal wounds. It was all a long, long time ago, and all those involved are very different people today.

Nevertheless, soon after the birth of Mary's daughter Kristine, the divorce came. It was the appropriate thing to do, but divorce was considered rather scandalous in those days, and it was something she was rather ashamed of. But Mary was still young, and quite pretty, and determined to make it in the world. At 21 years old, even with two kids in tow, it still didn't take her long to find another husband.

He was a recently-returned, decorated veteran (bronze star and two purple hearts, amongst others) of the Vietnam war named Gary. He was a Border Patrol agent at that time. He was at the start of a very long and successful career with the Immigration & Naturalization Service, first as Border Patrol, then as Special Agent, and eventually retiring as assistant director for investigations in the state of Texas.

He was a very good man in many ways, although sometimes emotionally cold, and like so many stepfathers who'd never had kids of his own, was less understanding with children than he at times should have been. He could be alternately affectionate and harsh, and occasionally just plain mean. It was hard to predict which side of him you might see in those days. On the other hand, it would be easy to make Mary out as a saint, and she was not one; at times she was rather manipulative, and she tended to try to make herself the center of attention. She was constantly caught up in her own personal dramas, and sometimes played out her own issues through her children.

Still, Gary and Mary were mostly happy together, in the beginning, and the kids were doing okay. A few years into the marriage, though, Mary gave birth to Gary's first son, Michael Harlan, who unfortunately had severe birth defects. He died within days. Both Mary and Gary took that very hard, and it seems that their marriage began to crumble around that time. They did have another son together before the end, who they named Gary, after his father. Recently, young Gary followed in his father's footsteps, first joining the Border Patrol, and now recently having been promoted to special agent within the newly-formed Department of Homeland Security.

Not long after Michael Harlan's death, however, it started to become apparent that Mary had some profound problems. Her own mother had suffered from mental problems, so much so that in the 1950s she'd been institutionalized for a while, and underwent shock therapy. Mary began exhibiting the same symptoms as her mother had, and began spiralling into the depths of that horrible disease, that hellhole known as profound mental depression. Having a second child with Gary did not help pull her through it.

There in the late 1970s, mental health problems still carried a fairly severe stigma. Whether diagnosed or undiagnosed, severe depression was looked down on with contempt and misunderstanding. Although today we understand that these things are medical problems that can usually be treated, in those days that was less widely understood and far less accepted.

Eventually, Mary and Gary divorced, and she wound up alone again, this time with three children: Dean, Kristine, and young Gary. Child support payments and occasional reliance on the welfare system kept them afloat, but Mary's ability to cope eventually collapsed. The children over the next few years were alternately separated and brought back together, in constantly varying arrangements that never worked out to anyone's real satisfaction.

By the time her son Dean hit 15, he was an angry, rebellious, resentful, and cynical young man who did not particularly like anyone in his own family. He left home slightly before his 16th birthday, and never came back. He would go several years at a time having no contact with Mary, his father, his siblings, or any of his other relatives, as he generally wanted little or nothing to do with any of them.

It was not until he was in his late 20s that Mary's son Dean started learning how to forgive, how to place the lives and actions of those young people and the demons that sometimes drove them into some kind of perspective. By the time he reached the age of 30, he'd all but lost the ball of anger that had for so many years seemed permanently lodged in his chest.

Indeed, it was in trying to get his upbringing into perspective, to understand who those young people he called his parents were, that he finally realized that he cared about them after all.

But now let me tell you a few more things about Mary. She gave her son Dean certain gifts when he was a child that he has carried with him throughout his entire lifetime since, and I'd like to tell you about a few of those.

Her greatest gift to him was, of course, life itself.

Her second greatest gift was that she instilled a love of the written word into him. His earliest and happiest memories as a child involve sitting in his mother's lap while she read to him, encouraging him to learn the letters and the words. It was their favorite activity together, and by the time he reached school age he was already reading and writing well in advance of his peers.

She gave him her at-times goofball, at times subtle wit.

She gave him a sense of introspection and, although he's sometimes overused that particular gift, he knows it is a blessing in the end.

She gave him the gift of empathy, the ability to really care about other people's feelings, and to realize that hurting someone's feelings isn't particularly admirable.

She helped him to learn to forgive others for their sins--and to forgive himself for his own.

She helped him to understand just how desperately important fathers are in their children's lives, and how having children is a deep and abiding responsibility--yet that parents are human, and can never be perfect.

But most of all, she gave him the gifts of life and love.

Now I'd like to tell you a few more brief things about Mary, and then I'll be done.

She reads this weblog every day.

She is a big fan of her son's writing.

She turns 54 today.

Happy birthday, Mom. I love you.

Posted by dean | PermaLink | TrackBack (4)

Discuss This Article!

 

Happy Birthday, Mrs. Dean's Mom. Fine boy ya' got there.

Posted by Mrs. du Toit on January 18, 2004 at 3:38 AM


And he turned into a liberal. This is how he honors you? With a son like that I'd take up marathon bridge playing, or something like that.

Seriously, glad you're still with us. Hope you're doing well. And when Dean gets a little above himself remember, children are their grandparents' revenge.

Posted by Alan Kellogg on January 18, 2004 at 3:49 AM


Dammit Dean, ya fogged up my glasses with that! A beautiful tribute...

Posted by Gregory Markle on January 18, 2004 at 4:04 AM


Happy Birthday, Mary!

Whoa, Dean -- knocked the wind out of me.

Posted by Thinks Too Much on January 18, 2004 at 4:10 AM


Beautiful, baby boy. Just beautiful.

Happy birthday, Dean's Mom. You have a wonderful son.

Posted by margi on January 18, 2004 at 4:25 AM


Happy Birthday Mom,

Jake and I love you too!

Posted by Rosemary the Queen of All Evil on January 18, 2004 at 7:06 AM


Happy Birthday, Dean's Mom! ;-)

Posted by Paul Burgess on January 18, 2004 at 7:59 AM


Happy Birthday, Dean's Mom! Your son's blog is one of my favorites.

Posted by Peg C. on January 18, 2004 at 8:13 AM


Thanks, Mary, for never giving up. And many happy returns.

Posted by Ara Rubyan on January 18, 2004 at 9:23 AM


Happy B-Day.

Dean is a wonderful person! Operation Give would never have happened without his support. His love and generosity is easy to see.

Posted by Plunge on January 18, 2004 at 10:06 AM


May the warmth of your love overcome the sadness of days gone by. May the joy of goodness of each happy thought cover the clouds of past rainy days. Happy birthday and remember to also love yourself for you have created love.

Posted by QuantumThnk on January 18, 2004 at 10:29 AM


Happy Birthday to your Mama, Dean! She raised a terrific blogger. And her daughter-in-law is the Queen of All Evil.



Happy Birthday, Mary!!!!!!!!
I have had t he opportunity to hang out with Dean a couple of times, and he is indeed a wonderful, caring person. And a fun guy too!!!
Have a great day.

Posted by sid on January 18, 2004 at 1:49 PM


Mighty fine post Dean.

Happy Birthday Mary.

Posted by Ralph Stefan on January 18, 2004 at 2:28 PM


You've proven you are not just an insightful analyst of politics and culture, but also an artful storyteller. Happy birthday to your mom.

Posted by susan on January 18, 2004 at 2:30 PM


Thanks for sharing Mary's story and giving readers a taste of the possiblities one can build from a flawed early life (are there any other kinds?). Learning to forgive is the greatest gift the stormy, angry soul will ever receive. I speak from experience.

God bless Dean's mother, Mary and all the Esmays.

Posted by jane m on January 18, 2004 at 2:48 PM


Happy Birthday Dean's Mom!!

Ya done good.

Posted by Anticipatory Retaliation on January 18, 2004 at 3:19 PM


Happy Birthday Dean's Mom! I'm waiting for the movie or book based on your life's experiences. Here's hoping each year brings you more joy than the previous ones and new friends to spend it with.

Posted by Tim the Soldier on January 18, 2004 at 6:15 PM


Happy Birthday Dean's Mom!

Posted by yak on January 18, 2004 at 7:08 PM


Have you ever thought about heros? The first people I think of are firemen and policemen and ambulance-drivers (people with sirens :) But, that reveals a very common bias: That they are heros all the time. We forget that heros are ordinary people who do the right thing, in spite of how hard and horrifying it is. We forget that heros make mistakes like the rest of us, that they can be both a hero and a sinner. This doesn't diminish them, rather highlights the heights they had to scale in the first place. Perhaps even trying to scale the heights can make you a hero, that keep-trying attitude in the face of difficulty. The heart to wish that things were "better" without knowing exactly how to accomplish that. Struggling against our own limitations. Honor is in the striving, not neccessarily the conquering.

I suspect that sometimes heros forget with the rest of us that they are only human, filling with regret about things not done, or things done wrong. Concentrating on entirely the wrong things. So. Here's a gift for Dean's Mother:

Gift: Dean is obviously a brilliant and gifted writer, and a real sweetie (we ALL know this because he's the kinda husband that will go on a diet with his wife, which still amazes me), a good person who deserves his very charming wife and very sparkly-cute son. And somewhere he managed to aquire the grace to apologize when wrong. And he's smart. And he's good at using his influence to help people (ie ChiefWiggles). And the world is a nicer place because he shares his thoughts through this blog. Even if the only thing you ever did was to give him life instead of aborting him, that would make you a hero. Imagine yourself in that JimmyStewart movie "Its A Wonderful Life". Imagine there was no Dean (hence a "different" life for Rosemary and no Jake), how that would change the world for the poorer. Dwell on that. Then, remember that you have FOUR children. You managed to give the world the best of you FOUR times, as hard as it was and as much as it personally cost you.

Perhaps people will dismiss that, the idea that having children makes you a hero. But ... Mary didn't have to have children. Mary could have yielded to other's choices. Mary could have curled up in a ball and slipped away inside herself so far that no one ever found her again. Mary could have stopped trying, but she didn't and the world is better for it. Thats the "hero" part.

Call to Action: Call your mothers. Call any mothers you like. Tell them you've also been thinking about JimmyStewart and "Its A Wonderful Life". Tell them you think the world would be a worse place without them. Admittedly, it may give them pause that its the middle of January and you're still thinking about Christmas movies. But, few people are upset when you call to tell them something nice. If you want to add that personal note of eccentricity, wait and call them in July to talk about Christmas movies :)

Posted by Allison on January 18, 2004 at 7:09 PM


Happy Birthday Mary.

Posted by Starhawk on January 18, 2004 at 8:42 PM


Being a mom, a new mom at that. I truly loved reading this.
You never know as a parent if what you are doing is the right thing. You do your best, follow your instincts and love, love, love. Then, you hope for the best.
I just hope that with all the mistakes I'm sure to make as a mother, my daughters will one day look at me with the same admiration that you, Dean do for your mother.

Happy Happy Birthday, Mary!!

Posted by Mary on January 18, 2004 at 10:08 PM


But Dean, what about your older brother?

Posted by Gary Utter on January 19, 2004 at 12:16 AM


As it happens, I spoke to him this evening, after a very long hiatus.

What of him? :-)

Posted by Dean Esmay on January 19, 2004 at 12:49 AM


Oh my dear and precious son, there is so much I want to say in response to the most beautiful words I have ever seen in print.

Tears of emotion have overcome me so many times reading this over, and over, and over again until my heart sang a song of joy I had not sang for many many years Dean. You see precious, Mother's do count too too many of our mistakes as our years go by instead of our good measures.

Oh Dean...once again those tears are rolling down your Mother's cheeks right now as I try to tell you just how very proud your MaMa is of you, and how deeply moved beyond any words I can possibly write. I just can't find them honey.

I too love you and your Mothers soul is soaring precious.

Posted by Mary on January 19, 2004 at 4:40 AM


...I must add...These most Greatest Names bestowed upon me in giving live... and then when Rosemary Honored me.

First...MOTHER. When my daughter in law first called me Mom! You can not imagine the awesome love and honor I felt in being called Mom by the love of my sons Wife...Rosemary.

And the day my Grandson was born...Jacob. To be called, GRANDMA! I sing, I dance to a new beat in my heart, and the melody has just begun for for me & for this adorable young lad...Oh Jacob, Grandma Jaja dances a new dance because of you sweetheart, and it is because your Mommy and Daddy gave you live... and my love & my blood runs through you.

Ahh...how I will slumber tonight Rosemary, & Jacob, with a happy joyful heart, and read my Bible. I will go to one of my most favorite and what I believe, to be one of the most beautiful passages in the bible that tell us how we already planned to come into this world through a divine being I chose to call God. That verse is in Psalm-139.

Yes Dean...I did come into this world January 18, 1954 to give you LIFE... and it was already planned even befored I was concieved!

Put your arms around my daughter Rosemary for me and hold her lovingly, and strong and tell her she is your Mother treasure.

I had to come back once more to post to let your wonderful family how much more my life has been blessed beyond human words can be expressed so I will say, I love you so very much Rosemary my darling daughter and my adorable grandson jacob!

I THANK GOD FOR YOU AND GIVING BIRTH TO JACOB!

tears are just overcoming me. this is the most beautiful birthday...i will cherish forever.

Oh thank you, thank you...Dean



What of him? :-)

In the early stages of this piece, you set him up as a mystery, then you casually dismiss him as having been tracked down years later without ever saying his name.

Did he suffer? Did he thrive? Is he running for the Democratic nomination for President? Did he sleep with Pamela Anderson? Is he Moby?

Posted by Gary Utter on January 19, 2004 at 12:34 PM


Ah. I didn't tell you much about Kristie either.

John is married with children and living in the state of Washington. He's had a moderately rough life but no worse than many. To no one's great surprise, he is a musician and a writer. He and mom made it onto the nightly news in San Antonio when they had their first reunion, in 1987.

There is, of course, much more I could tell you, but this thread is my mom's story.

By complete coincidence, my sister Kristie now lives in the same area as John, with her three children and her fiancee. She works now for the state of Washington.

Posted by Dean Esmay on January 19, 2004 at 1:02 PM


Oh my gosh Dean...it is Mom! I just reread all the birtday blessings and noticed that through my tearful eyes I posted how I came into this world in 1954, oh...you can see and tell how much I was overcome. I still am.

Thank you Son, Thank you.



 



.:: ABOUT DEAN'S WORLD ::.


.:: BEST OF DEAN'S WORLD ::.


.:: RECENT ENTRIES ::.


.:: ARCHIVES ::.


.:: MISC ::.