Okay, not really. But John and I are going at it pretty hot and heavy in the Dowdifying Scalia thread. Yet somehow, we haven't killed each other yet.

Think that's not interesting? Well, maybe not, until you discover that:

Dean thinks gay people are fools not to join the Republican Party!

John thinks Republican fundamentalists are dangerous!

John thinks States' Rights are a null concept!

Dean thinks 9th-amendment expansionists are flirting with tyranny in the name of civil rights!

All that and more awaits! To see the debate, search for "Jim Bennett" and his message about some new Republican silliness, and just start reading from there. I'm going to try my best to give John the last word though--if he wants it.

Anyone else should feel free to chime in, but only if you can keep it civil--and I hope anyone who does so will read what's there already before responding!

(This is one for our Best Discussions archive.)