Dean's World
 Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

.:: Dean's World: Google News Controversy ::.

May 17, 2003

Google News Controversy

I got a note from Gil Shterzer telling me that Google News was carrying hate-stories from the IndyMedia site "again." This sort of surprised me because, having seen stuff from the Stalinist Worker's World Party, as well as stuff like IndyMedia on there before, I thought they'd always done that.

That turns out not to be the case. The generally level-headed Meryl Yourish is blogging on this issue, as is the somewhat more controversial but usually reliable LGF.

Something like this does bring up questions about what should be counted as a news organization and what shouldn't. There's always the worry over censorship in these cases. But surely a comprehensive news-crawler should have some discriminatory powers between services, right? I don't need stuff from Neo-Nazi newsletters, Free Republic, Democratic Underground, or execrable sites like Bartcop or IndyMedia or the Worker's World Party newsletter, showing up as "news." Do you?

I suggest that a polite note to the Google News people is in order, as Meryl suggests.

Posted by dean | PermaLink | TrackBack (0)

Discuss This Article!

 

If anyone cares to see it, here's the note I sent:

I was rather disappointed to learn recently that Google News is including material from such hate-sites as IndyMedia in the list of sites that it indexes and displays for news searches. I've gotten "news" stories from these folks, and from such insane sources as the Worker's World Party newsletter, from Google News in the past. I'm hoping you'll either cut the crawling of such pernicious sources, or at least give readers a way to filter them. I don't want Neo-Nazi information, or stuff from right-wing sites like Free Republic, shown to me as "news" any more than I want to see stuff like this. I hope you'll consider making a policy change in this area. Thanks.

Dean Esmay

Posted by Dean Esmay on May 17, 2003 at 2:53 AM


Alternatively, the word may just go out that the news judgment of "Google News" is not to be trusted. And that would sorta cut into the attraction of reading it.

Posted by McGehee on May 17, 2003 at 10:03 AM


 



.:: ABOUT DEAN'S WORLD ::.


.:: BEST OF DEAN'S WORLD ::.


.:: RECENT ENTRIES ::.


.:: ARCHIVES ::.


.:: MISC ::.